Love the fit (I am a bit of an athletic cut, tall and slim) Good for cool but not cold temps, does a great job of keeping me dry and stopping the wind. Zippers are good and easy to work, zippered pockets are a plus (I always drop things)It fits great and is very warm, though I got it in early Spring, it hasn't been tested is serious winter cold yet.I chose this rating for efficiency and perfect the product, I like that it looks exactly like what I saw on pageI bought this shell for my brother for Christmas. It was much lighter weight than I expected, and definitely not warm enough for where he lives, but it is still a nicely made jacket. I bought it thinking it would zip into his Columbia jacket, since its labelled as interchangeable. Nope, no way. The zippers are not compatible at all, but this is an issue with Columbia's labeling. I've looked at other shells since and others also listed as interchangeable will not zip in and others that are not listed as interchangeable will.